Davin News Server

House GOP Presses NOAA Over Key Data Missing In Its Billion-Dollar Disasters Report
by Nick Pope
Sep 6, 2024

House Republicans are pressing the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Association (NOAA) for answers about a 
signature dataset frequently cited as evidence that climate change is intensifying. 

Members of the House Committee on Science, Space, and Technology Committee wrote to NOAA Administrator 
Richard Spinrad on Wednesday demanding information about several aspects of the agency's "billion-dollar 
disasters" (BDD) dataset, which the Biden administration has cited to justify its pause on natural gas export 
terminal approvals, among other things.

The lawmakers allege that the BDD data may be violating NOAA's scientific integrity rules, and they also 
requested clarification on NOAA's methodology and an explanation as to why the agency does not adjust for 
variables like GDP.

The metric's critics have pointed out that economic statistics are an inappropriate proxy for climate 
change's intensity or changing meteorological conditions.

For example, identical storms in identical locations at two different times would render different damage 
totals because of increases in the amount of property in harm's way and not necessarily because climate 
change has gotten any worse.

"Since the 1990s, NOAA has published annual reports showing the number of disasters that have cost more than 
a billion dollars in damages," the letter states. "Debate around the validity of the reports' methodologies 
has resulted in NOAA making incremental but important changes. Since 2011, the reports' cost estimates of all 
past disasters in the dataset have been updated annually to account for inflation in today's dollars."

"However, despite adjustments for inflation, the reports have not been adjusted for increases in population 
or wealth in the same capacity," the letter continues.

"Due to these increases in population and wealth, even mild storms can sometimes appear to cause greater 
damage today. The lack of updated, comprehensive data in these models raises considerable concern given that 
these reports have been cited by both Congress and the President as the justification for different federal 
government actions concerning climate change."

BDD data was used in a flagship climate report released by the Biden administration in 2023, and it was also 
cited as evidence to justify the administration's pause on approvals for new liquefied natural gas export 
terminals by Deputy Energy Secretary David Turk in testimony provided to Congress in February.

The letter alleges that NOAA's inflation adjustments appear inconsistent in some cases. Additionally, the 
lawmakers wrote that the opaque methodology for deriving BDD data makes the data nearly impossible to 
independently replicate and verify.

The letter's authors - Republican Reps. Frank Lucas of Oklahoma, Max Miller of Ohio, and Jay Obernolte of 
California - called on Spinrad to disclose why NOAA connects BDD data and climate change and the scientific 
basis it has for doing so, as well as for an explanation as to why the agency does not adjust its data for 
increases in population or wealth.

Roger Pielke Jr., a BDD critic and former environmental studies professor at the University of Colorado, 
raised several of these issues in his correction request submitted to NOAA in January.

In response to his request, NOAA said it would be taking steps to improve the BDD data's transparency.

NOAA referred the Daily Caller News Foundation to the statement it issued upon releasing its response to 
Pielke's correction request when contacted for comment on this story. An agency spokesperson added that the 
agency will respond to the lawmakers' letter via official channels.

"NOAA notes that the did not identify specific data points that need correcting. In its review of the RFC, 
NOAA has not identified any data inaccuracies in the Billion-Dollar Disaster data set," an agency 
spokesperson said in a statement shared with the DCNF regarding Pielke's correction request.

"NOAA has determined the U.S. Billion-Dollar Weather and Climate Disasters data set meets the threshold for 
influential scientific information (ISI) under NOAA's Information Quality Guidelines. As a result, NOAA will 
review and update its management practices for the data set."

=====

August:

Early Snows Hit Kyrgyzstan

Eastern U.S. Fells Cold Records, 150 Million To See Fall-Like Temps

UK's Coolest Summer Since 2015

First Significant Snows Forecast For The Alps

150 Years Of Antarctic Ice Data Reveals Decline In Wildfires Since 1920

Arizona Sees August Snow

Europe Forecast Stark Temperature Drop

Thousands Without Power In Tasmania As Cold And Snow Intensify

Foot Of Snow Closes Going-To-The-Sun Road

Rare August Snow Clips Montana's Peaks

Earth's Oceans Are Cooling Fast, And Scientists Have Yet To Come Up With A Party-Approved Reason Why

Snow In Wyoming And Colorado

August Snow Has U.S. Resorts Planning For Winter

Rare Snow And Century-Old Cold Records Fall In California

Rare August Chill Breaks Decades-Old Records

Rare August Snow For The Sierra Nevada

The Atlantic's Rapid Cooling

Heavy Snow Hits New Zealand's South Island

Record Summer Chills Sweep The Great Lakes, Northeast, and Southern Canada

Where Are The Hurricanes? Another Crushing Defeat For Team Climate Change

Antarctica Registers -75.5C (-103.9F), Sea Ice Surges

Winter Far From Over In New Zealand

Historical "Heatwave Days" Show No Trend

Researchers Pumped Extra CO2 Into A Forest, And Biodiversity Thrived

Low Temperature Records Fall In U.S.

Frosts Persist In South America, Impacting Coffee Prices

Island Nations Like Tuvalu: Growing, Not Sinking

Record Cold Sweeps Brazil

Antarctica Back Below -70C (-94F)

Summer Snowfall at Khardungla Pass

Polar Bear And Arctic Sea Ice Lies Persist

Polar Fronts To Hit South America

Antarctic Sea Ice Extent Gains 1 Million Km2 In A Week

Frigid Winter Forecast For NH

Vast Cold Wave About To Sweep The U.S.
Greek Study Challenges CO2-Temperature Causality
Arctic Shipping Season Is Shortening
Rapid Antarctic Sea Ice Growth
Heavy Snow Hits New Zealand
Too Many Polar Bears In Greenland
British Farmers Paid To NOT Produce Food
Record July Cold Hits Scotland
Summer To Quit Early This Year
Remarkable Summer Gains On The Greenland Ice Sheet
Arctic Sea Ice Extent: No Cause For Alarm
$78 Trillion To Fight The Hoax of 'Climate Crisis'