Davin News Server

Charleston's Climate Lawsuit Against Oil Giants Is Dismissed

The legal claim, one of a raft of lawsuits across the country, had accused companies of a yearslong disinformation campaign about 
climate change.

By Karen Zraick
Aug. 6,2025

A judge in Charleston, S.C., dismissed on Wednesday the city's lawsuit against oil and gas companies over their role in climate 
change, ruling that the case raised questions that were far beyond the bounds of state laws.

During two days of hearings in May, lawyers for the city argued that the companies, ranging from giants like Exxon Mobil and 
Chevron to local firms, had covered up what they knew about the dangers of greenhouse gas emissions. They accused the companies of 
mounting a disinformation campaign to cast doubt on climate science and failing to warn the public about the dangers ahead.

Those actions increased demand for fossil fuels, which led to emissions and the grave risks linked to climate change that the 
historic coastal city now faces, including flooding and sea-level rise, they argued. The case cited state tort laws and the state's 
Unfair Trade Practices Act and sought funds for adaptation and mitigation projects.

In his 45-page decision, Judge Roger M. Young wrote that while the lawyers argued the claims were about deception, "they are 
premised on, and seek redress for, the effects of greenhouse gas emissions." He said that those issues fall squarely under federal 
and not state law, and that the court lacked jurisdiction over out-of-state companies.

He cited a 2021 decision by the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit in a similar lawsuit filed by New York City against 
oil companies. In that case, Judge Richard J. Sullivan of the Circuit Court addressed whether the municipalities could use state 
tort laws to hold multinational companies liable for damages caused by greenhouse gas emissions.

"Given the nature of the harm and the existence of a complex web of federal and international environmental law regulating such 
emissions, we hold that the answer is 'no,'" Judge Sullivan wrote.
Image
A man in a dark blue suit and white shirt stands at a podium and gestures with his hands as he speaks.
Lawyers for the city argued that companies including Exxon Mobil and Chevron had covered up with they knew about the dangers of 
greenhouse gas emissions.Credit... Madeline Gray for The New York Times

In Charleston, the defendants argued that the lawsuit was pre-empted by federal law, and that the case raised political questions 
that should be addressed by other branches of government.

The city declined to comment immediately after the ruling. A spokeswoman said that Charleston was considering whether to appeal.

Roughly three dozen similar cases have been filed across the country since 2017, mostly by Democratic-led states, cities and 
municipalities. Charleston's case was filed in 2020 by a Democratic mayor and allowed to continue by his Republican successor. 
South Carolina's attorney general, Alan Wilson, also a Republican, had submitted an amicus brief to the court supporting the 
defendants' arguments.

Charleston was an early test of the Trump administration's possible impact on these lawsuits. In April, President Trump issued an 
executive order calling the legal complaints a threat to national security, saying they could lead to crippling damages. That led 
the Justice Department to file unusual lawsuits against Hawaii and Michigan seeking to prevent them from filing their own climate-
change suits. (Hawaii filed soon afterward, and Michigan may still do so.) Judge Young asked each side to weigh in on the impact of 
the executive order on their cases, but did not discuss the filings in the decision.

Theodore J. Boutrous Jr., who represents Chevron and argued on behalf of all of the companies before Judge Young in Charleston, 
applauded the decision. He said it added to a "growing chorus" of dismissals in climate lawsuits, including in cases brought by 
Baltimore, New Jersey and Bucks County, Pa., among other places.

But supporters of the litigation point to three state supreme courts that have affirmed lower court rulings against the companies' 
motions to dismiss, in cases brought by Boulder, Colo., Honolulu and the state of Massachusetts.

In Charleston, Judge Young echoed decisions in favor of the defendants in other cases, writing that the lawsuits would create a 
"chaotic web of conflicting legal obligations" for companies as municipalities imposed de facto regulations on fossil fuels. The 
remedy 'must rest with the federal political branches that are legally and substantively equipped to address them," he wrote.

Judge Young also expressed concern that the theory of liability in the case "appears almost limitless." Under its logic, he wrote, 
"virtually anyone could be a plaintiff - and a defendant - in what would effectively amount to a perpetual series of lawsuits that 
reset after every storm."

=====

August:

Global Temperatures Drop Sharply
The World Weather Attribution Scam
GFS Spins Up Two Fantasy Hurricanes

Patagonia's Increasing Snow
Cold And Snow Sweep South Africa
China's Solar Bubble Pops: 87,000 Jobs Gone, More Pain Ahead
Rise And Decline Linked To Hunga-Tonga

Ludhiana Logs Coldest July in 15 Years
More Monthly Cold Records Fall Across Australia
California's Record Cool Summer

Global Temperatures Continue To Drop
Australia Record Cold, Snow, And Power Failures
Arctic Sea Ice Doing Fine

2025 In The U.S. Is Running Cool
Perth Chills, Sydney Shivers

Southern Hemisphere Slammed Into Winter
European Alps Freeze
Kenya's Cold Sends Power Demand To Record Highs
USA Today Cries 'Extreme Heat' - Forecast Shows Anomalous Cold

Alps See Snow As Europe Holds Cold
Magnitude 8.8 Quake Rattles Kamchatka
Medieval Antarctica Was Warmer, Study 

Europe's "Dog Days" Feel Like Autumn
Snow Returns to WA as Cockatoos Freeze in the Victorian Alps

Australia's Snow Season Delivers
Record Cold Up North
Europe Set For Historic Lows With A Foot Of Snow Over The Alps
Global Temperatures Continue To Slide 

Perth Shivers
Western Europe Chills
Summer Snow At Gilgit-Baltistan, Pakistan
Alberta Town Breaks 118-Year Cold Record
The Butterfly Panic Narrative Falls Apart
Exceptional July Cold Grips Russia
N. California's Coldest Summer
Antarctic Fronts To Sweep Australia
New Zealand Nears All-Time July Lows
West Arctic Sea Ice Higher Than 1981
Greenland Overrun
Cyclone Activity At Record Lows
+ Extreme Weather Deaths At An All-Time Low 
Record July Cold in Yakutia and Beyond
Cooler 2025 For The U.S.
New Study On Urban Heat
+ Solar Quiet, But X-Flare Risk Remains
July 21, 2025 Cap Allon6 Comments	
Record Cold Sweeps Parts Of The U.S.
Ross Ice Shelf To -60C (-76F)
The North Atlantic Is Cooling
+ Warming Pause In Australia
United States 3.6F Below Average
Thwaites Glacier Hysteria
"Homogenization": The Past Must Be Cooled
+ Solar Shockwaves
Polar Cold Slams Northern Rockies
Germany's Worst Floods Were Centuries Ago
Africa's Sea Levels Were 1m Higher 2,000 Years Ago
+ Volcanic Activity Surges