Davin News Server

AI/LLM Reviews of  Star Trek The Next Generation - A fistful of Datas  

Google Gemini

Plot Synopsis
The Enterprise is testing a new trilithium power coil, and the tests require Data and Geordi La Forge to link Data’s positronic net to the main computer. Meanwhile, Commander Worf, Counselor Troi, and Worf's son, Alexander Rozhenko, are spending time together in a holodeck simulation of the fictional Wild West town of Deadwood, enjoying Worf’s favorite program, "The Sundown Kid."

During the power coil tests, an unexpected energy surge ripples through the ship's systems. This surge, combined with Geordi's attempts to reroute power, causes a massive data transfer that accidentally uploads Data's entire personality matrix into the holodeck’s resident computer core.

The Western simulation characters—Sheriff Worf, the bartender, the townsfolk, and the outlaws—begin to take on the characteristics of Data. Not only do they gain Data's appearance (all played by Brent Spiner), but they also acquire his superhuman strength, logical ruthlessness, and rapid processing speed. Worf, Troi, and Alexander are trapped as the safety protocols fail, forced to battle an army of identical, emotionless, and deadly androids. The only way out is for Geordi to reverse the complex process and save Data before the trapped crew members are killed.

Strengths
Comedic Value of Multi-Spiner: The sheer visual comedy of having Brent Spiner play multiple, identical holographic characters is the episode’s greatest asset. Watching "Data" characters deliver Western clichés ("Draw!") with the android's characteristic formal, stiff delivery is genuinely entertaining and often hilarious.

The Worf/Alexander Dynamic: This episode is a great vehicle for developing Worf's relationship with his son, Alexander. They are forced to rely on each other to survive, allowing Worf to demonstrate practical survival skills and fatherly protection in a unique, high-pressure scenario.

Data's Unique Characterization: The story uses the holodeck characters to mirror Data's core personality traits—his logic, his strength, and his lack of emotional subtlety—making his absence keenly felt and demonstrating why he is unique, even when clones are present.

Weaknesses
The Holodeck Malfunction Trope: This episode relies on the single most overused plot device in TNG: the Holodeck Malfunction. By Season 6, the audience is well-aware that the holodeck safety protocols will fail, which diminishes the surprise and stakes.

Technical Jargon Overload: The crisis resolution is purely technological, involving Geordi and Picard throwing around complex technical terms ("trilithium coil," "positronic matrix," "heuristic algorithms") to explain the problem and the fix. This tends to sideline the action for long stretches.

Low Stakes for the Senior Crew: Characters like Captain Picard and Dr. Crusher are primarily relegated to exposition on the bridge or in Engineering, leaving the main action to Worf, Troi, and the various Brent Spiner clones.

Overall Impression
"A Fistful of Datas" is a fun and memorable episode, primarily thanks to Brent Spiner’s exceptional performance as multiple characters. It fully commits to its Western theme while delivering an entertaining survival scenario. While it's weak on originality (using the standard holodeck malfunction), it succeeds by using that framework to deliver a genuinely unique, funny, and action-packed hour. It’s a solid example of the lighter side of TNG's sixth season.

Rating: 7.5/10

ChatGPT

Here’s my take on **“A Fistful of Datas”** (TNG, Season 6, Episode 8) — what works, what doesn’t — and a rating out of 10.

---

## Summary / What Happens

* While the *Enterprise* is delayed, the crew take advantage of free time. Data and Geordi propose linking Data’s positronic brain into ship systems as a backup. Meanwhile, Alexander persuades Worf to join him and Troi in a holodeck western program set in Deadwood, South Dakota, as sheriff, deputy, and mysterious stranger, respectively. ([Memory Alpha][1])
* A power surge or malfunction causes elements of Data’s computational processes to invade and corrupt the holodeck program: characters begin to look and behave like Data, and safety protocols fail. ([Jammer's Reviews][2])
* In the holodeck, Worf, Troi, and Alexander confront an antagonist, **Frank Hollander** (who looks like Data), and discover more Data-type figures. The simulation becomes dangerous. ([TV Tropes][3])
* On the ship, Data and Geordi race to fix the corruption, restoring the computer and holodeck to normal. In the final holodeck confrontation, Worf rigs a personal force shield to protect himself from Data-like opponents until he can disarm them, rescues Alexander, and the program ends. ([Cygnus X-1][4])
* Afterward, Worf seems to accept (with Alexander) that future holodeck adventures are possible; he puts on his cowboy hat in his quarters. ([Cygnus X-1][4])

---

## What Works / Strengths

1. **Fun, Light-hearted Tone & Genre Play**
   This is one of the more playful, “just for fun” episodes. The Western setting, the holodeck malfunction, and the Data mania give it a whimsical spirit. The show leans into genre homage. LatetotheGame describes it as giving actors a chance to enjoy themselves, especially Brent Spiner’s performance. ([Late to the Game Blog][5])

2. **Brent Spiner / Data Flexibility**
   As always in such episodes, Spiner shines. When the holodeck characters begin adopting Data’s traits, accents, mannerisms, that gives him room to “ham it up” in a controlled way. Jammer’s Reviews notes Spiner as the best part: even when the episode is weak, he gives its energy and presence. ([Jammer's Reviews][2])

3. **Interesting Idea of Identity Crossover**
   The notion of Data’s “image” leaking into holodeck facsimiles, making threats that are Data clones, is a decent spin on holodeck-gone-wrong tropes. The merging of computer system corruption with virtual world bleed is conceptually neat.

4. **Some Character Moments, Especially Worf & Alexander**
   The Worf–Alexander relationship is again a focus. Alexander wants to get Worf into the fun of the holodeck, and Worf is resistant but slowly immersed. Also, Worf improvising with his shield (inside the rules of the scenario) is a nice “character meets tool” moment. LatetotheGame highlights that the real story is about Worf and Alexander. ([Late to the Game Blog][5])

5. **Production / Direction Touches**
   The Western staging, costume, lighting, holodeck setpieces are serviceable. The direction (by Patrick Stewart) helps keep pace from sagging in the fight sequences. Bradley’s Basement praises the direction and the opportunity for visual touches (e.g. the opening interruptions to Picard’s flute) as charming. ([Bradley's Basement][6])

---

## Weaknesses / Criticisms

1. **Underwritten / Thin Stakes**
   Many reviews and critics say the episode feels skeletal: the danger is never fully threatening, and many of the Western clichés are played superficially. Jammer’s mentions it is “shockingly lifeless, bloodless, and joyless” in its Western parts. ([Jammer's Reviews][2])
   The holodeck plot is, in effect, a long riff on “the holodeck goes wrong,” without deep consequences.

2. **Tone & Pacing Issues in Genre Shifts**
   The pacing sometimes feels sluggish, as scenes shift from ship to holodeck. The Western segments, which should feel dynamic, sometimes drag because the series still works at a somewhat deliberate pace, which doesn’t always suit action/combat sequences. Jammer’s compares it unfavorably to *Rascals* in that regard. ([Jammer's Reviews][2])

3. **Character Underuse / Sidelining**
   Some cast members barely figure into the story. Many of the regular crew are essentially spectators—most of the drama is in the holodeck or on the engineering side with Data/Geordi. The emotional arcs beyond Worf/Alexander are minimal.

4. **Clichés & Familiar Tropes**
   Because it’s a genre homage, many of the story beats are predictable (the bad guy looks like Data, safety protocols off, improbably strong holo-opponents). The episode relies heavily on the novelty of Data’s malfunction more than exploring deeper meaning.

5. **Resolution Is Convenient**
   The final fix—rigging a shield, disarming Data clones, restoring systems—is serviceable but doesn’t push boundaries. The holodeck ending hinges on an emotional gesture (one “Data” playing Annie embracing Worf) to break the simulation. Some viewers see that as too neat.

---

## Overall Impression & Rating

*A Fistful of Datas* is not a deep or seriously ambitious episode, but I think it works pretty well **for what it aims to do**: a fun, genre-flavored, playful break in the season. It gives Spiner room to stretch, revisits Worf/Alexander dynamics, and leans into a fun hoedown of holodeck mischief. It won’t be remembered as one of TNG’s moral or philosophical high points, but among holodeck / genre episodes it’s a pleasant entry.

**My Rating: 6.5 / 10**

* If it were held to the standard of Trek’s best, it falls short in depth, stakes, and character development.
* But as a “just for fun,” enjoyable, light episode, it over-delivers relative to many filler episodes.

If you like, I can compare *A Fistful of Datas* to other holodeck or genre episodes (e.g. *Elementary, Dear Data*, *The Big Goodbye*) to see where it ranks. Do you want me to do that?

[1]: https://memory-alpha.fandom.com/wiki/A_Fistful_of_Datas_%28episode%29?utm_source=chatgpt.com "A Fistful of Datas (episode) - Memory Alpha - Fandom"
[2]: https://www.jammersreviews.com/st-tng/s6/fistful.php?utm_source=chatgpt.com "\"A Fistful of Datas\" | Star Trek: TNG - Jammer's Reviews"
[3]: https://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pmwiki.php/Recap/StarTrekTheNextGenerationS6E8AFistfulOfDatas?utm_source=chatgpt.com "Star Trek: The Next Generation S6E8 \"A Fistful of Datas\" Recap"
[4]: https://www.cygnus-x1.net/links/lcars/epsd-TNG6-8.php?utm_source=chatgpt.com "\"A Fistful of Datas\" (S6:E8) Star Trek: The Next Generation Episode ..."
[5]: https://latetothegame.blog/2020/05/30/retro-tv-review-star-trek-tng-ssn-6-episode-eight-a-fistful-of-datas-2/?utm_source=chatgpt.com "Retro TV Review: Star Trek TNG SSN 6 Episode Eight: A Fistful Of ..."
[6]: https://bradleybasement.wordpress.com/sci-fi/star-trek/a-fistful-of-datas-tng-tv/?utm_source=chatgpt.com "'A Fistful of Datas' (TNG) (TV) | Bradley's Basement - WordPress.com"


-- 
Member - Liberal International This is doctor@nk.ca Ici doctor@nk.ca
Yahweh, King & country!Never Satan President Republic!Beware AntiChrist rising!
Look at Psalms 14 and 53 on Atheism ;
All I want to hear from JEsus Christ is WEll done Good and Faithful servant