Davin News Server

AI/LLM Reviews of Star Trek The Next Generation - Aquiel   


Google Gemini

Plot Synopsis
The Enterprise investigates a missing Starfleet officer, Lieutenant Aquiel, whose shuttle was found adrift near a remote starbase. The situation quickly turns into a suspected murder case when evidence points toward foul play, particularly after they find the only survivor: a non-humanoid, crystalline organism known as a coalescent entity, which has consumed the starbase's commander.

The investigation is led by Commander Riker, but the focus quickly shifts to Lieutenant Commander Geordi La Forge. Geordi had been exchanging romantic personal logs with Aquiel and had grown attached to her, leading him to become emotionally compromised and even, briefly, a chief suspect in the eyes of the Klingon exchange officer, Commander Morag.

The mystery unravels as Geordi, Data, and Troi piece together the confused timeline. They discover the coalescent entity has been impersonating Aquiel's beloved pet dog (a Gorn-like creature called a "Worf") and manipulating events. In a final twist, they find the real Aquiel, who had been hiding in a cryogenic storage locker aboard the shuttle, alive and well. She is ultimately cleared, and the entity is contained.

Strengths
Geordi's Drive: The episode offers a strong emotional drive for Geordi La Forge. While the execution is flawed, the premise of an intensely dedicated engineer being the central figure in a murder mystery adds a unique dynamic, forcing him out of the engineering bay and into the uncomfortable role of detective/suspect.

The Worf/O'Brien Scene: A small but much-loved moment of comic relief occurs when O'Brien attempts to bond with Worf by reading a volume of Klingon poetry, an interaction that perfectly captures the awkward human-Klingon cultural divide.

Atmosphere: The isolated setting of the starbase and the shuttle craft lends the episode a genuine feeling of tension and isolation befitting a mystery, effectively utilizing the shadowy corners of the Federation frontier.

Weaknesses
The Geordi Trope: The episode is heavily criticized for once again portraying Geordi La Forge as romantically inept and socially awkward, continuing a painful trend for his character that many fans found demeaning. The uncomfortable idea that he could be a suspect because he was "too interested" in a woman does not age well.

Weak Villain: The "coalescent entity" is a confusing, poorly defined, and ultimately unsatisfying antagonist. It is more of a plot device than a compelling threat, making the resolution feel contrived and rushed.

Underwhelming Conclusion: The revelation that Aquiel was simply hiding in a locker, rather than being the victim or the hidden villain in a sophisticated plot, deflates the tension built up by the prior events, leaving the audience with an anticlimactic ending.

Overall Impression
"Aquiel" attempts a solid Star Trek mystery but falls short due to an over-reliance on a problematic character trope and a confusing, poorly integrated "monster-of-the-week" resolution. While it has a few memorable moments (primarily comedic ones involving the supporting cast), the central mystery is weak and the character work for Geordi is unsatisfying. It's often cited as a weaker effort in an otherwise strong season.

Rating: 4.5/10

That episode is definitely a polarizing one!

ChatGPT

Here’s a detailed review of ***Star Trek: The Next Generation – “Aquiel”*** (Season 6, Episode 13) based on the script at [chakoteya.net/NextGen/239.htm](http://www.chakoteya.net/NextGen/239.htm), along with a rating out of 10.

---

## 🧭 Summary

The Enterprise investigates a **Federation communications station** near the Klingon border after losing contact with it. When the away team arrives, they find one of the two officers apparently **murdered**—reduced to a puddle of organic residue. The surviving officer, **Lt. Aquiel Uhnari**, has gone missing.

As **Geordi La Forge** and **Riker** investigate, Geordi begins reviewing Aquiel’s personal logs. He becomes emotionally attached to her through her recordings, developing romantic feelings before even meeting her—a callback to Geordi’s recurring theme of falling for women through simulation or distance.

When Aquiel is found alive, suspicion falls on her for the death of her crewmate, **Lt. Rocha**. However, the investigation uncovers that the real culprit may be a **coalescent lifeform**—a shapeshifting alien that consumes and replicates organic matter, leaving its victims’ remains behind. In the climax, it’s revealed that the creature is actually disguised as **Aquiel’s dog**, and Geordi has to destroy it.

The episode ends with Aquiel cleared of charges, but her potential romance with Geordi left unresolved.

---

## 🧩 What Works

### 1. **A Rare Geordi-Centered Episode**

LeVar Burton rarely got emotionally complex stories outside the engineering room, and “Aquiel” gives him a chance to explore vulnerability, attraction, and disappointment. His performance is nuanced—genuine, lonely, and hopeful without becoming pathetic.

### 2. **Film-Noir Mystery Vibe**

The first half of the episode sets up a promising *murder mystery in space*. The logs, the empty outpost, and the alien residue create a moody, investigative tone—something like a sci-fi noir. The slow-burn pacing of the investigation is initially effective.

### 3. **An Interesting Alien Concept (On Paper)**

The coalescent organism—a shapeshifter that consumes people and assumes their form—is a neat idea, reminiscent of *The Thing*. The concept could have carried a darker, more suspenseful story.

### 4. **Atmospheric Design and Direction**

The abandoned communications station, dark corridors, and eerie residue lend a good sense of isolation. The tone is visually distinct from the Enterprise’s bright, sterile corridors.

---

## ⚠️ What Doesn’t Work

### 1. **Weak Chemistry Between Geordi and Aquiel**

While the episode *wants* to be a tragic romance, the chemistry between Geordi (LeVar Burton) and Aquiel (Renée Jones) feels awkward and forced. Their scenes together lack emotional depth, and the script doesn’t give them time to develop believable intimacy.

### 2. **Muddled Story Focus**

The episode starts as a murder mystery, morphs into a romance, then pivots into a creature-feature ending. These tonal shifts make it feel disjointed, as if three different drafts were merged without cohesion.

### 3. **Uninspired Resolution**

The shapeshifting dog reveal is almost unintentionally comical. The “monster dog” effect is cheap, and it deflates what could have been a chilling ending. What begins as an intelligent investigation ends like a B-grade horror episode.

### 4. **Wasted Potential for Themes**

The episode flirts with compelling themes—loneliness, projection, trust, and the dangers of falling for an idealized image—but doesn’t follow through. Geordi’s emotional investment in a woman he barely knows could’ve been a fascinating exploration of human connection in isolation, but instead it’s brushed aside.

### 5. **Pacing Problems**

After a strong first act, the middle drags with repetitive dialogue and procedural filler. The third-act twist feels rushed, as if the writers realized they needed an ending but had run out of time.

---

## 💡 Standout Moments

* Geordi reviewing Aquiel’s logs and empathizing with her isolation is tender and well-acted.
* The quiet investigation scenes with Picard and Riker early on build good suspense.
* The reveal that the dog is the alien shapeshifter—while flawed—remains a memorable (if bizarre) Trek twist.

---

## 🧠 Themes

* **Isolation and empathy** – both Geordi and Aquiel are lonely individuals searching for understanding.
* **The danger of idealization** – Geordi’s affection for a woman he knows only through logs mirrors his past holodeck fantasies (*Booby Trap*).
* **Identity and trust** – a recurring TNG motif, but explored here only superficially.

---

## ⭐ Final Rating: **5 / 10**

**Verdict:**
“Aquiel” starts with promise—a moody murder mystery and a chance for Geordi to find meaningful romance—but it collapses under a weak script and clumsy tonal shifts. The final act’s absurd creature twist undermines the emotional groundwork, leaving the episode feeling hollow.

It’s **watchable**, even occasionally touching, but ultimately a **missed opportunity** that reinforces Geordi’s unfortunate pattern of unlucky love stories.

---

**In short:**
🧩 *Good idea, poor execution.*
🛠 *Solid Geordi performance, but weak storytelling.*
🐕 *Alien dog twist? Not TNG’s finest hour.*

**Rating:** ⭐ **5/10**
-- 
Member - Liberal International This is doctor@nk.ca Ici doctor@nk.ca
Yahweh, King & country!Never Satan President Republic!Beware AntiChrist rising!
Look at Psalms 14 and 53 on Atheism ;
All I want to hear from JEsus Christ is WEll done Good and Faithful servant