Davin News Server

Ai/LLM reviews of Star Trek: Deep Space Nine - "The Abandoned" 

Google Gemini

Rating: 7.5/10

Overview

"The Abandoned" features two distinct, parallel storylines. The main plot centers on Quark, who purchases Gamma Quadrant wreckage and discovers a large, hostile alien infant. The infant turns out to be a Jem'Hadar, one of the Dominion's primary shock troops, and his rapid maturation forces the DS9 crew to try and socialize a creature fundamentally bred for violence. The secondary, lighter plot involves Commander Sisko attempting to guide his son, Jake, through his first serious romantic relationship with Mardah, a Dabo girl working at Quark's.

Review

"The Abandoned" is a strong episode, primarily for its intense and revealing main plot concerning the Jem'Hadar. This is the first time the crew interacts with a single, highly-developed Jem'Hadar, and the story does an excellent job of exploring the nature-versus-nurture debate. The Jem'Hadar, whom they name "Tossy" (though he soon insists on his real designation, First Omet'iklan), is a fascinating, tragic figure. Dr. Bashir and Odo clash over how to handle the creature—Odo, knowing the Jem'Hadar are genetically engineered to obey and be violent, believes they should be cautious and treat him as a threat, while Bashir tries desperately to teach him morality and independence.

The episode delivers a chilling message: some things are so fundamentally engineered that they cannot be changed through gentle influence. Omet'iklan's inevitable decision, driven by his genetic imperative for violence and obedience, is a powerful moment that underscores the terrifying nature of the Dominion.

The B-plot with Sisko and Jake is a charming, necessary counterweight to the darkness. It provides welcome character development for Jake and shows Sisko in a very human, slightly awkward fatherly role as he tries to be the "cool dad" while guiding Jake's love life. While entertaining, the A-plot is what elevates the episode.

The primary weakness is that the resolution is somewhat abrupt and the ethical quandaries raised are simplified by the Jem'Hadar's biology, but overall, it's a tense, character-driven story that enhances the threat of the Dominion.

Key Strengths:

Jem'Hadar Introduction: Provides a chilling, close-up look at the Dominion's shock troops and their genetically-driven nature.

Odo's Insight: Odo's understanding of the Jem'Hadar's engineered nature is both tragic and necessary.

Sisko/Jake Dynamic: A great, lighthearted subplot that adds emotional depth to the Sisko family unit.

Ethical Conflict: Effectively explores the nature vs. nurture theme in a science fiction context.

ChatGPT

Here is a **review of *Star Trek: Deep Space Nine* – “The Abandoned” (Season 4, Episode 6)**, based on the episode content reflected in the Chakoteya transcript and the episode itself, followed by a rating out of 10.

---

## Review: *The Abandoned*

“The Abandoned” is a quiet but powerful episode that uses a small-scale story to explore **nature vs. nurture, responsibility, and the limits of compassion**. Rather than focusing on galactic politics or action, it zeroes in on one deeply personal moral dilemma.

The episode centers on **Odo**, who discovers an injured **Jem’Hadar child** left behind after a battle. Hoping to prove that the Dominion’s soldiers are not inherently violent, Odo takes the boy under his care. What follows is less a redemption story and more a tragic examination of whether some forms of conditioning are too deeply embedded to undo.

### Strengths

* **René Auberjonois delivers a nuanced, restrained performance**. Odo’s hope, frustration, and eventual sorrow feel earned and deeply in character. His belief in personal choice clashes painfully with reality.
* The episode does excellent **world-building for the Dominion**. It makes clear that the Jem’Hadar are not merely soldiers, but biologically and psychologically engineered weapons.
* The moral conflict is classic DS9: there is no easy answer, no triumphant solution, and no reset button. Odo’s failure is not due to cruelty or negligence, but because goodwill alone isn’t enough.
* The Jem’Hadar youth is portrayed not as a monster, but as someone who never had the chance to be anything else — making the outcome more tragic than frightening.
* The story subtly reinforces the growing threat of the Dominion without relying on battles or spectacle.

### Weaker Points

* The Jem’Hadar child is necessarily underdeveloped as a character; his role is symbolic more than personal, which may limit emotional connection for some viewers.
* The pacing is deliberately slow and introspective, which may feel subdued compared to more action-heavy episodes.
* Some viewers may find the conclusion bleak, as it offers understanding but no real victory.

### Overall Impression

“The Abandoned” is a thoughtful, somber episode that fits perfectly into *Deep Space Nine*’s moral landscape. It challenges the optimistic Star Trek assumption that empathy and guidance can fix everything, and instead suggests that systems of oppression can create damage that individuals alone cannot undo.

It’s not flashy, but it’s thematically rich — and very much in the spirit of DS9’s more mature storytelling.

---

## ⭐ Rating

**8.5 / 10**

A strong, emotionally grounded episode that deepens the Dominion arc and Odo’s character, offering a sobering reminder that not all tragedies can be prevented, even with the best intentions.

-- 
Member - Liberal International This is doctor@nk.ca Ici doctor@nk.ca
Yahweh, King & country!Never Satan President Republic!Beware AntiChrist rising!
Look at Psalms 14 and 53 on Atheism ;
Merry Christmas 2025 and Happy New Year 2026